Site Navigation

Home
About
Services
Testimonials
Contact
News
FAQ

Mitch’s Sports Cards & Collectibles

"Your Trading Card Headquarters!"

About Us

Mitch's Sports Cards & Collectibles, located in Mequon, WI, is a distinguished trading card store renowned for its exceptional selection. We cater to both passionate enthusiasts and avid collectors with an extensive inventory of sports cards. From rare vintage classics to contemporary treasures, our collection guarantees quality and authenticity. Dedicated to providing an unparalleled shopping experience, Mitch's is the must-visit destination for sports card lovers in Mequon and surrounding areas. Explore our impressive range, where passion and expertise unite, and find your next prized possession today.

Areas Served

What We Offer

Our Specialties include:

Sports Cards
Sports Card Breaks
Memorabilia
Baseball Cards
Basketball Cards
Signed NFL Jerseys

Our Services include:

Sports Card Breaks – Join in on the excitement of live sports card breaks, where sealed boxes and packs are opened in real time and cards are distributed based on your purchased spots or teams. It’s a thrilling way to collect rare inserts, autographs, and memorabilia cards while connecting with fellow collectors.
Grading – We offer professional card grading services to authenticate, evaluate, and protect your most valuable cards. Partnering with trusted grading companies, we ensure your cards are accurately assessed for condition and encapsulated for long-term preservation and value.
Sports Collectibles – Explore our curated selection of sports memorabilia, from autographed jerseys and balls to vintage programs and display-worthy keepsakes. Each item is chosen for its authenticity, quality, and ability to bring fans closer to the game they love.

Our Brands include:

Topps
Panini
Leaf Trading Cards
Fanatics
Pokémon

Our Products include:

Soccer Cards
Memorabilia
Pokémon Cards
Hobby Boxes
Trading Card Games
Signed NFL Helmets
Baseball Cards
Prism Cards
Signed NFL Jerseys
Basketball Cards
Hockey Cards
NBA Cards

Testimonials

On 12/28/2025 Zig Justice had this to say:
This store is outstanding. They've got a big selection of stuff, both sports and TCG, but Mitch and Cullen are heroes when it comes to helping people grow, sell, and otherwise enjoy their collections. They're not just running a business; they're enthusiasts themselves, not to mention friendly and incredibly helpful. They'll help with card grading, or selling collectibles, and offer services for selling things on auction on consignment. Solidly reliable, too. I stopped in because I was hoping to sell some high-value collectible TCG stuff I had. I had contacted other stores, but nobody else was willing to work with such high value items. Mitch got back to me literally the next morning with a buyer lined up, and they handled shipping, insurance, and communicating with the buyer. Since they've got a lot of connections in the collectible card industry, and are comfortable with and competent in handling high value collectibles, they're definitely a trustworthy resource and provide an immeasurable amount of added value for someone like me who doesn't have any reputation on auction sites and struggles with shipping and insuring collectibles. 100% worth a visit, and they're going to be my first stop from now on when it comes to buying and selling!

On 12/11/2025 Kyle Sheane had this to say:
Very Nice Store with a huge selection of sealed product. The guy working Cullen is very knowledgeable and courteous while answering all my questions. I will be coming back.

On 9/23/2025 Karen Heller had this to say:
Great experience selling vintage baseball card with Cullen at Mitch's Sports Cards! I wanted to sell my dad's vintage baseball card, but had no idea what it was worth or how to sell it. Other shops told me to get the card graded. They either had no interest in the raw card, or would pay a few hundred for it. But when I called Mitch's and talked to Cullen, he convinced me it would be worth it to have it graded. Then he went above and beyond, offering to send it in for me. Who does that?! He could have bought it cheap, then had it graded and sold it himself. His integrity is remarkable! Not only that, but he gave me solid advice on selling the card - best method and how to price it. All his recommendations were spot on, resulting in a quick sale at a high price. He kept me informed during the process, was always responsive via text, and patient with my questions. I highly recommend doing business with Cullen. He's a really nice, helpful guy you can trust to buy/sell cards.

On 9/4/2025 skillert69 had this to say:
Good selection. Reasonable prices.

On 9/2/2025 Eric had this to say:
Big selection of stuff and lots of singles to choose from! I really have to pace myself going in there, there's just too much I want!!! Testimonial written by Eric on this site.

Contact Us

Mitch’s Sports Cards & Collectibles
11235 N Cedarburg Rd Mequon, WI 53092
Phone: (262) 302-4209
Email: mitchreid2000@yahoo.com

We are located next to Café Hollander Mequon

Where To Find Us

Payment Types Accepted

Discover, American Express, Debit Cards, MasterCard, Visa, PayPal, Apple Pay, Android Pay, Venmo, Zelle, Cash App

Our Hours

Holiday Hours May Vary. Please Call For Details.

Monday: 10:00 AM - 8:00 PM
Tuesday: 10:00 AM - 8:00 PM
Wednesday: 10:00 AM - 8:00 PM
Thursday: 10:00 AM - 8:00 PM
Friday: 10:00 AM - 8:00 PM
Saturday: 10:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Sunday: 10:00 AM - 4:00 PM

News

On 12/22/2025 this was posted:
Elevate Your Collection at Mitch’s Sports Cards & Collectibles!

Looking for rare sports cards, memorabilia, and collectibles? At Mitch’s Sports Cards & Collectibles, we bring you the best in hobby boxes, singles, and exclusive finds for every fan and collector.

✅ Wide selection of sports cards & collectibles
✅ Authentic memorabilia for true enthusiasts
✅ Friendly service & expert advice

📍 Visit us today or shop online at mitchssportscardsandcollectibles.com to score your next big addition!

🏈 Exciting news for NFL fans! We now have signed NFL jerseys available! 🎉 Don't miss the chance to grab your favorite player's autograph. Limited stock, so act fast! 🛒 #NFL #SignedNFLJerseys #FanGear

🎉 Weekend goal: complete your sports collectibles wishlist! Whether it's adding rare sports cards to your album or discovering unique baseball cards in hobby boxes, it's all about the chase. Show off your new prized memorabilia with Mitch's Sports Cards! 🏅 #TradingGameCards

Unlock the true potential of your sports card collection! Graded baseball cards and memorabilia from hobby boxes can turn your hobby into a treasure trove. 🔍💎 Stop in today and see what we can do for your collection!

Our hobby boxes are stocked with premium baseball cards and collectibles for every fan. Discover rare gems and unforgettable memorabilia today! Stop in today to see what we have to offer.

FAQ

Where can I find information about upcoming breaks and new collectibles?

Follow our Facebook for updates on upcoming breaks, new arrivals, and featured collectibles: https://www.facebook.com/p/Mitchs-Sports-Cards-Collectibles-100084969215591/

What grading services do you offer?

We partner with trusted grading companies to authenticate, evaluate, and encapsulate your valuable cards, ensuring accurate condition assessment and protection.

What types of products do you offer for collectors and fans?

We offer a diverse range of products including soccer cards, Pokémon cards, hobby boxes, and trading card games. Our memorabilia selection features signed NFL helmets and jerseys, while our card collection includes baseball, basketball, hockey, NBA, and prism cards, catering to all types of collectors and sports enthusiasts.